By Michael Pepsin Avorgah, GNA
Denu (V/R), Nov. 19, GNA – A Denu High Court, presided over by Mr Sylvester Nii Okai Ablor, has quashed the Anlo Traditional Council Judicial Committee ruling in the Atorkor Dufia Stool chieftaincy dispute.
The ruling, delivered on November 18, 2026, followed an application for judicial review by way of certiorari, challenging the jurisdiction of the Anlo Traditional Council to adjudicate the dispute, which the applicants argued fell within the Kome-Shime Traditional Area.
The decision invalidated the proceedings and ruling delivered by the Council on February 18, 2026, in Suit No. ATC/13/23, involving Torgbi Ackumey Geli Adjorlolo III and others against Sylvanus Afetorgbor and another.
The applicants, led by Torgbi Dosu Adaku VIII of Atorkor, sought an order to bring the Council’s decision before the High Court for it to be quashed.
The Anlo Traditional Council, Anloga, was named as respondent, while Torgbi Ackumey Geli Adjorlolo III, Courage Adjorlolo and Michael Jones Fenu, all of Atorkor, were listed as interested parties.
The dispute was between the Dosu Adaku and Ackumey Geli Adjorlolo families over the rightful occupant of the Dufia stool of Atorkor.
The interested parties-initiated proceedings before the Anlo Traditional Council on February 19, 2023, seeking a declaration that it was unlawful for the defendants to install a chief as Dufia of Atorkor, by virtue of an earlier judgment of the Council.
On July 3, 2024, Sylvanus Afetorgbor and Dr Dennis Kofi Adaletey filed a statement of defence on behalf of the Dosu Adaku Stool. The Judicial Committee first sat to hear the substantive matter on August 13, 2025, and delivered its final ruling on February 18, 2026, with Torgbi Samlafo IV of the Avenor Traditional Area as Chairman and Torgbi Kpemini Gawu V and Torgbi Hatsu III, both of the Kome-Shime Traditional Area, as members.
The elders and kingmakers of the Dosu Adaku Stool held an emergency meeting after the ruling and resolved to challenge its validity.
They filed a motion on notice at the Denu High Court on May 15, 2026, supported by an affidavit sworn by Samuel Ephraim Gemadzi, the second applicant, who said he had the authority and consent of the other applicants.
They contended that the Council lacked statutory jurisdiction because Atorkor, where the two competing stools are located, falls within the Kome-Shime Traditional Area, a separate and independent traditional jurisdiction with its own Traditional Council and Judicial Committee.
They argued on three grounds: that the Council acted without or in excess of jurisdiction; that it wrongfully assumed territorial authority over a matter within Kome-Shime; and that the panel was improperly constituted.
They also questioned the participation of Togbi Samlafo IV of Avenor, Togbi Kpemini Gawu V of Whuti and Togbi Hatsu III of Dzita, arguing the panel lacked statutory authority to hear the dispute under the Anlo Traditional Council.
Relying on Articles 270 and 274 of the 1992 Constitution and the Chieftaincy Act, 2008 (Act 759), the applicants argued that the jurisdiction of Traditional Councils was limited by their recognised traditional area boundaries.
They cited Republic v Kumasi Traditional Council; Ex parte Dei (1973) 2 GLR 73 and Republic v Judicial Committee of the Central Region House of Chiefs; Ex parte Aaba (2001-2002) SCGLR 545, to support the position that statutory bodies could exercise only jurisdiction expressly conferred on them.
They further argued that consent, silence or participation could not confer jurisdiction where the law did not give it, citing Republic v High Court, Koforidua; Ex parte Bediako II (1997-98) 1 GLR 488, Agbemabiese v Carboo (1994-95) GBR 392 and Macfoy v United Africa Co. Ltd. (1961) 3 All ER 1169 – that an act which is void is a nullity.
The ruling is a victory for the applicants on jurisdiction. It does not determine which family is entitled to occupy the Dufia stool of Atorkor.
That question, the Court implied, must be determined by the appropriate traditional jurisdiction – Kome-Shime.
GNA
Edited by Maxwell Awumah / Christopher Arko/Benjamin Mensah